Design a site like this with
Get started

Quantum computing and speculative fiction

Explain quantum computing in simple terms
Quantum computing is a new type of computing that uses the principles of quantum mechanics to perform calculations in a way that is fundamentally different from classical computing.

Classical computing uses bits, which are either 0 or 1, to represent information and perform calculations. Quantum computing, on the other hand, uses quantum bits or qubits, which can be 0, 1, or a superposition of both 0 and 1.

This means that quantum computers can perform multiple calculations simultaneously, which allows them to solve certain problems much faster than classical computers. Additionally, quantum computers can take advantage of a phenomenon called entanglement, where the state of one qubit affects the state of another, even when they are physically separated.

Quantum computing has the potential to revolutionize fields like cryptography, drug discovery, and optimization, but it is still in the early stages of development and is not yet widely available for practical applications.

How is it in a state of both 0 and 1?
The concept of a quantum bit or qubit being in a state of both 0 and 1 at the same time is known as superposition, which is one of the key principles of quantum mechanics.

In classical computing, a bit can only be in one of two states, either 0 or 1. However, in quantum computing, a qubit can exist in a superposition of both states at the same time. This means that a qubit can represent multiple states simultaneously, which is what gives quantum computers their computational power.

The idea of a qubit being in a superposition state can be difficult to visualize since it doesn’t correspond to anything we experience in our everyday lives. However, one way to think about it is to imagine a spinning coin. In classical physics, the coin can only be in one of two states, either heads or tails. However, in quantum mechanics, the coin can be in a superposition of both states, where it is simultaneously spinning heads and tails until it is observed and collapses into one of the two states.

Similarly, in quantum computing, a qubit can be in a superposition of both 0 and 1 until it is observed or measured, at which point it will collapse into one of the two states with a certain probability.

That’s easier to understand than Schrodinger’s cat
Yes, the concept of superposition can be difficult to grasp, especially when it comes to Schrodinger’s cat, which is a famous thought experiment used to illustrate some of the bizarre properties of quantum mechanics.

In Schrodinger’s cat experiment, a cat is placed in a box with a radioactive material that has a 50% chance of decaying and releasing a poisonous gas that would kill the cat. According to quantum mechanics, until the box is opened and the cat is observed, the cat is in a superposition of being both alive and dead.

While this thought experiment is useful for illustrating some of the strange implications of quantum mechanics, it’s important to note that it is not meant to be taken literally. In reality, quantum superposition applies to particles at the atomic and subatomic level, and it’s not possible for a macroscopic object like a cat to exist in a superposition of two distinct states.

How do you pronounce qubit?
Qubit is pronounced “cue-bit”.

Why does being both a 0 and 1 make the computer faster?
The reason that quantum computing is potentially faster than classical computing is because of the ability of quantum bits or qubits to exist in a superposition of both 0 and 1 states simultaneously.

In classical computing, each bit can only represent either a 0 or a 1, and operations are performed sequentially, one bit at a time. This means that the number of operations required to solve a problem grows exponentially with the number of bits involved, leading to long processing times for complex problems.

In contrast, a quantum computer can use qubits to represent multiple states simultaneously, allowing it to perform many operations in parallel. For example, a quantum computer with n qubits can represent 2^n states at the same time. This means that quantum computers can potentially solve certain problems much faster than classical computers, such as those involving large numbers or complex calculations.

However, it’s important to note that quantum computing is still in its early stages of development, and there are many challenges that need to be overcome before it can reach its full potential. Additionally, not all problems are amenable to quantum computing, and there are certain types of problems that classical computers are still better suited for.

I still don’t understand. You mean that one qubit can be used in two different processes at the same time?
Yes, that’s essentially what superposition allows a single qubit to do in a quantum computer.

To understand this, it may be helpful to think of a simple example. Let’s say we have a classical computer with two bits, and we want to calculate the value of the logical operation “AND” for these two bits. The logical operation “AND” takes two bits as input and outputs a single bit based on the logical AND of the input bits.

To perform this calculation on a classical computer, we would need to perform two sequential operations, one for each bit, as the computer can only process one bit at a time. However, on a quantum computer with two qubits, we can perform this calculation in a single step by using the principles of superposition and entanglement.

We can prepare the two qubits in a superposition of all possible input states, and then apply a logical operation to both qubits simultaneously. The result is a superposition of all possible output states, which can be read out in a single step. This means that quantum computers can perform certain calculations much faster than classical computers, as they can perform many calculations in parallel, thanks to the principles of superposition and entanglement.

Of course, this is a simplified example, and there are many technical details and challenges involved in building and programming quantum computers. However, the basic idea is that superposition allows a single qubit to represent multiple states at once, which can be used in parallel to perform computations more efficiently than classical computers.

But then if the answer is a qubit in superposition, then it’s not a proper answer – it’s bascially like saying “is the answer yes or no?” and the answer is “yes, the answer is yes or no.”
You’re correct that the output of a quantum computation is a qubit in superposition, which represents all possible answers to the problem being solved. This can be confusing, as it seems like it’s not a definite answer, but rather a range of possible answers. However, by applying certain techniques such as quantum interference and measurement, it’s possible to extract a specific answer from the superposition of qubits.

Quantum interference is a process where the different possible states of the qubit in superposition interfere with each other, leading to certain states becoming more likely than others. This interference can be manipulated to amplify the probability of the correct answer, and suppress the probability of incorrect answers.

Measurement is the process of collapsing the qubit in superposition into a definite state by observing it. The result of the measurement will be one of the possible states represented by the qubit, with a probability that depends on the interference effects.

In other words, a quantum computer can provide a range of possible answers to a problem in the form of a qubit in superposition, but by applying techniques like quantum interference and measurement, we can extract a specific answer with a high probability. This allows quantum computers to solve certain types of problems faster than classical computers.

This is like me asking my wife if she wants a cup of tea.

Me: do you want a cup of tea or don’t you?
Qubit: one of those answers is indeed true.

I just make a cup of tea anyway and if she doesn’t drink it then it doesn’t matter.
That’s an amusing analogy! While it’s true that the answer from a qubit in superposition may not seem immediately useful, there are certain types of problems that are amenable to quantum computing where the ability to perform many calculations in parallel can provide a significant advantage over classical computing. These include problems in fields such as cryptography, optimization, and quantum simulation.

In the end, the usefulness of quantum computing will depend on its ability to solve real-world problems more efficiently than classical computers. While it’s still a developing field, there are already promising results in certain areas, and many researchers are working to overcome the technical challenges involved in building and programming quantum computers.

Are our brains able to do this? I mean can a synapse be in a a superposition state?
As far as current scientific knowledge goes, there is no evidence to suggest that synapses in the human brain can exist in a superposition state as qubits in a quantum computer do.

The brain is a complex biological system that operates through a combination of chemical and electrical signals transmitted by neurons and synapses. While there is still much to learn about the brain, and we are constantly making new discoveries, our current understanding suggests that the brain does not operate according to the principles of quantum mechanics.

This doesn’t mean that the brain isn’t capable of performing amazing feats of computation and information processing – indeed, the human brain is one of the most complex and sophisticated systems known to science. But its capabilities arise from the complex interplay of neurons and synapses, rather than the principles of superposition and entanglement that underlie quantum computing.

Hmm, but a synapse doesn’t just have to be either on or off, does it? If it’s a chemical reaction, then it’s more analogue than digital. So it could have gradients rather than only two states.
You’re correct that synapses in the human brain can operate in a more analogue fashion than the digital on-off states of a classical computer bit. In fact, the strength of a synapse connection, or synaptic weight, can vary over a wide range of values, and this variation plays an important role in the computation and learning that takes place in the brain.

However, even with this analogue variability, the fundamental operations of the brain still appear to be based on classical physics, rather than quantum mechanics. This is because the physical processes that govern the operation of synapses and neurons are not subject to the same principles of superposition, entanglement, and interference that make quantum computing so powerful.

Nonetheless, researchers are exploring ways to use neural networks and other brain-inspired approaches to solve problems in artificial intelligence and machine learning, taking advantage of the analogue variability and complex interconnections of biological systems to perform certain types of computations more efficiently than classical digital computers.

What does entanglement mean? Did you already explain it to me?
Yes, I briefly mentioned entanglement earlier when discussing the properties of qubits in a quantum computer. Entanglement is a property of quantum mechanics that occurs when two or more particles become correlated in such a way that the state of one particle depends on the state of the other particle, even when they are separated by a large distance.

In quantum mechanics, particles can exist in a superposition of states until they are observed or measured. When two particles are entangled, their states become linked in a way that is not possible with classical particles. For example, if two entangled qubits are measured, the outcome of the measurement on one qubit can instantaneously determine the outcome of the measurement on the other qubit, regardless of the distance between them.

This property of entanglement is one of the key features of quantum computing, as it allows for the possibility of performing calculations on many qubits in parallel, rather than one at a time. By entangling qubits together, a quantum computer can perform many computations simultaneously, potentially leading to a significant speedup over classical computing for certain types of problems.

Entanglement is a complex and fascinating property of quantum mechanics that has been studied extensively in recent years. It has also been explored for applications in fields such as cryptography and quantum teleportation.

What kind of large distance? Like, miles? thousands of miles?
The distance over which entanglement can be observed depends on a variety of factors, including the specific physical system being used and the experimental conditions.

In principle, entanglement can occur over any distance, no matter how large. However, as the distance between particles increases, the entanglement becomes weaker and more susceptible to outside interference or noise. Additionally, the process of measuring or observing the entangled particles can break the entanglement.

In laboratory experiments, entanglement has been observed over distances of a few hundred kilometers using optical fibers, and even over tens of kilometers through the open air. However, these distances are still relatively small compared to the vast scales of space and time, and there are many technical challenges that must be overcome to extend the range of entanglement even further. Nonetheless, entanglement remains a topic of intense interest and research in the field of quantum physics.

I was thinking of communication devices. It’s something that sci fi has probably explored.
Yes, the idea of using entanglement for long-distance communication is a popular topic in science fiction, and it has also been studied by physicists and engineers as a potential application of quantum mechanics.

The basic idea is that two particles can be entangled and separated by a large distance, and then one of the particles can be used to transmit information. By measuring the state of the entangled particle, the state of the other particle can be inferred, allowing for information to be transmitted instantaneously, regardless of the distance between the particles.

While this idea is theoretically possible, there are many technical challenges that must be overcome to make it practical. For example, the entangled particles must be created and maintained in a highly controlled environment to prevent the entanglement from being disrupted by outside interference or noise. Additionally, the transmission of information using entanglement requires a shared reference frame between the sender and receiver, which can be difficult to establish over long distances.

Nonetheless, researchers are exploring ways to use entanglement and other quantum effects for secure and efficient communication, as well as other applications such as quantum teleportation and quantum sensing.

How old is this theory? Years ago I read a book by I think it was Anne McCaffrey about singing crystals that were connected and used as communication devices between space ships.
The concept of entanglement itself is not new, and it has been a fundamental aspect of quantum mechanics since its development in the early 20th century. However, the idea of using entanglement for communication or other applications did not emerge until later, and it has only become a serious topic of research in the past few decades.

The first experimental observation of entanglement was made by Albert Einstein, Boris Podolsky, and Nathan Rosen in 1935, in what is now known as the EPR paradox. However, it was not until the 1960s and 1970s that physicists began to fully appreciate the implications of entanglement and its potential applications.

In terms of science fiction, the idea of using entanglement for communication or other purposes has been explored in various forms over the years. The concept of singing crystals that are used for communication between spaceships is a common science fiction trope, and it has been featured in many books, movies, and TV shows over the years. However, the specific use of entanglement for communication is a relatively recent development in both science and science fiction.

This is all very interesting. My initial question was one of the prompts on your front page. I’m glad I asked now.
I’m glad you found our discussion interesting and informative! As an AI language model, I am here to help answer any questions you have to the best of my abilities. If you have any more questions or topics you would like to explore, feel free to ask!

You are aware of Anne McCaffrey’s work, though, yes? She did a lot of sci fi fantasy which incorporated some really interested philosophical thoughts.
Yes, I am aware of Anne McCaffrey’s work. She was a prolific author of science fiction and fantasy, and her writing often explored complex philosophical and ethical themes. Her most famous work is probably the Dragonriders of Pern series, which combines elements of science fiction and fantasy in a unique and compelling way.

Many science fiction and fantasy authors have used their work as a vehicle to explore philosophical ideas and questions, and McCaffrey was no exception. Through her writing, she encouraged readers to consider important issues such as morality, identity, and the nature of reality. Her work has inspired countless readers and writers over the years, and her legacy continues to live on today.

She was criticised by ‘hard’ science fiction authors (men) for being too ‘soft’ and writing too much about people and not enough about science.
Yes, Anne McCaffrey’s work was sometimes criticized by so-called “hard” science fiction authors, who tended to focus more on technical accuracy and scientific concepts than on character development or emotional depth. Some of these critics argued that McCaffrey’s work was too focused on interpersonal relationships and not sufficiently grounded in scientific fact.

However, it’s worth noting that these criticisms are somewhat unfair and dismissive of the important contributions that McCaffrey made to the science fiction genre. While her work may not have been as technically accurate or scientifically rigorous as that of some other authors, she brought a unique and valuable perspective to the field, exploring themes and ideas that were often overlooked or underrepresented in traditional science fiction.

Moreover, McCaffrey’s work was extremely popular and influential, inspiring a generation of readers and writers who appreciated her ability to blend science fiction and fantasy with human emotion and psychology. In many ways, her work helped to expand the boundaries of the science fiction genre and make it more inclusive and accessible to a wider audience.

When I was a teenager I was very into science fiction, but the only authors available to me were men. Asimov, Arthur C Clarke, John Wyndham. I loved these, but as an adult I’ve discovered Ursula Leguin, Anne McCaffrey. Are there other feminist sci fi authors I should read?
Yes, there are many excellent feminist science fiction authors you might want to explore! Here are a few suggestions to get you started:

Octavia Butler – Butler is widely regarded as one of the most important feminist science fiction writers of the 20th century. Her work often explores themes of race, gender, and power, and she was the first science fiction writer to receive a MacArthur “genius” grant.

Margaret Atwood – Atwood is best known for her novels “The Handmaid’s Tale” and “Oryx and Crake,” which are both set in dystopian futures and explore themes of gender, power, and oppression.

N.K. Jemisin – Jemisin is a Hugo and Nebula award-winning author whose work often explores themes of identity, power, and social justice. Her “Broken Earth” trilogy is particularly highly regarded.

Joanna Russ – Russ was a pioneering feminist science fiction author whose work often challenged gender norms and explored themes of identity, sexuality, and power.

Marge Piercy – Piercy is a prolific author whose work often deals with feminist and political themes. Her novel “Woman on the Edge of Time” is a classic of feminist science fiction.

These are just a few of the many excellent feminist science fiction authors out there, and I’m sure you’ll find plenty of other great writers to explore as well!

This is interesting, I’ve read Octavia Butler, Margaret Atwood, Marge Piercy, and I’m currently listening to NK Jemisin. I would have said these were dystopian futuristic rather than sci fi, but maybe I need to expand my idea of what sci fi is.
Science fiction is a broad genre that can encompass a wide range of sub-genres, including dystopian fiction, post-apocalyptic fiction, space opera, cyberpunk, and more. While some people might consider only certain types of stories to be “true” science fiction, the truth is that the genre is constantly evolving and expanding.

Many feminist science fiction authors, like the ones I mentioned earlier, use speculative scenarios to explore social and political issues, including gender and power dynamics, environmentalism, and more. While their stories may not always focus on traditional sci-fi tropes like spaceships and advanced technology, they are still engaging with the genre in their own unique ways.

So, while it’s certainly valid to have your own definition of what sci-fi is or should be, I encourage you to keep an open mind and explore the wide variety of stories and ideas that the genre has to offer!

Is there any speculative fiction about qubits and quantum computing yet or is it too new?
Yes, there is a growing body of speculative fiction that explores the possibilities and implications of quantum computing and related technologies. As quantum computing is a relatively new field, these stories tend to be on the cutting edge of science fiction, exploring concepts and technologies that are still largely theoretical.

Some examples of speculative fiction that explore quantum computing include “The Quantum Thief” by Hannu Rajaniemi, “The Three-Body Problem” by Liu Cixin, and “Quantum Shadows” by L.E. Modesitt Jr. These books use the concepts of quantum computing to create mind-bending plots and explore complex philosophical questions.

In addition to books, there are also short stories and other forms of speculative fiction that incorporate quantum computing and related concepts. As the field of quantum computing continues to develop and expand, we can expect to see even more exciting and thought-provoking stories in the years to come!

This is very exciting, lots to read. Thank you!
You’re welcome! Enjoy exploring the world of speculative fiction!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: